October 15, 2026
If a Pagosa Springs listing shows six years of strong vacation rental bookings, how much of that history do you get at closing? Under the rules on the books, often none of it. How long you wait to rebuild it depends on which side of a jurisdictional line the property sits.
That line divides three separate rulebooks: the Town of Pagosa Springs, unincorporated Archuleta County, and the Pagosa Lakes Property Owners Association. A buyer can get the price, the inspection and the financing exactly right and still find, after closing, that the rental income built into their math has to start over.
In unincorporated Archuleta County, the county's Land Use Regulations are blunt. Section 3.2.7.6 says that "unlike other Use Permits, a Vacation Rental Permit shall NOT run with the land in perpetuity." Those regulations cover the unincorporated county and expressly exclude incorporated towns, so properties inside Pagosa Springs Town limits follow a different code.
Inside Pagosa Lakes, the association tells buyers the same thing in its guidance on buying or selling within PLPOA: "STR licenses do not transfer with the property."
So the bookings calendar, the reviews and the revenue history on a listing all describe something the seller did. They aren't part of what the buyer receives. What changes from one jurisdiction to the next is how fast a new owner can get permitted again.
The county's rule is built for continuity. A new owner applies for their own Vacation Rental Permit after the sale closes. If they want to honor bookings the previous owner already took, the code requires the new application and fees "within thirty (30) calendar days after the closing date for the purchase, to avoid penalty." The new owner can't run advertising until the permit is approved.
The county code carves out two situations. An inherited property can carry its permit with it. Moving title between individuals and their trust or company, with the same people behind it, isn't treated as a change of ownership.
After an application is filed, the Planning Department inspects the home within 30 calendar days of a complete application with fees paid. It can add new conditions after any inspection. Permits last one year. If the renewal isn't filed before expiration, the permit is considered Closed, and a new application "will be subject to all standards and criteria in place on the date of application submittal." That last clause matters to anyone buying from a seller who let the renewal lapse. Rules adopted since the original permit can apply to the next application.
The Town of Pagosa Springs has taken a stricter approach, and a 2025 variance request showed how strict.
According to the Pagosa Springs SUN's account of the Feb. 18, 2025 Town Council meeting, the council considered a request for a one-time exception for a long-running vacation rental that was changing hands within a family. The request didn't seek to transfer the license, which the code doesn't allow. It sought to skip the rule that a new owner must own a property for two years before applying for a permit. The SUN quoted the Town code language behind the rule: "A vacation rental license is non-transferable," and a license "shall not create a continued right to operate a vacation rental beyond the term of the license."
Trusts don't get around it either. Town Clerk April Hessman told the council, as the SUN reported, that "when you start adding people to that trust, you've now changed who the owner is," which starts the two-year ownership requirement. The council denied the variance.
The SUN also reported the reasoning. Council member Gary Williams said the rule exists "because affordable housing is such a problem and we wanted to limit the number of houses shifting from rentals to short-term rentals so there would be more housing available for the workforce." The same story described a 10% cap in affected residential neighborhoods, discussed at a time when licenses were said to already exceed it. A neighborhood over its cap means that after a two-year wait, a new license still isn't guaranteed.
These Town rules come from 2025 reporting. Our research didn't turn up a later amendment, and we couldn't confirm the current Town code text either. For any property inside Town limits, the Town Clerk's office is the place to confirm today's rule.
Most buyers looking in the Pagosa Lakes area are in unincorporated county, so the county permit rules apply. PLPOA adds its own obligations on top of them.
PLPOA doesn't issue licenses, but it requires owners to notify it of vacation rental plans. Once the county approves a permit, the association flags the property as a short-term rental and applies a different assessment. Its Rules and Regulations require registration with PLPOA within 15 days after the county permit is issued, annual renewal, and giving renters the association's abbreviated vacation rental rules.
The assessment difference is large. PLPOA's published disclosures list the 2026 assessment at $365 for a standard property and $1,095 for a short-term rental property. Its assessment history shows 2025 figures of $335 and $1,005. Assessments are billed in January, due May 1, and carry a $25 late fee after that.
PLPOA also flags a structural issue. Its guidance says accessory dwelling units and guest houses aren't permitted under the PLPOA land use code. A unit that has existed for years "is not considered 'grandfathered' and does not grant the right to continue or replicate the use." A guest cabin advertised as a second income stream may carry no rental rights at all.
| Question at closing | Unincorporated Archuleta County | Town of Pagosa Springs, per 2025 reporting | Pagosa Lakes overlay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Does the permit convey? | No, it doesn't run with the land | No, the license is non-transferable | No, and PLPOA issues no licenses |
| When can a new owner apply? | After closing; within 30 days to keep existing bookings | After two years of ownership | Follows county permit, then 15 days to register |
| Inheritance | Permit may transfer | Two-year wait applied to the within-family transfer the SUN covered | Follows county |
| Trust or LLC with same owners | Not a change of ownership | Adding people to a trust counts as a change | Follows county |
| Cap | None in the code text cited here | 10% in affected neighborhoods | Not addressed |
| Extra annual cost | Permit renewal each year | Town license | $1,095 vs. $365 assessment in 2026 |
The rental economics in unincorporated areas could also change soon. On Aug. 18, 2026, the Archuleta County commissioners unanimously approved Resolution 2026-63, which puts a lodging tax increase on the Nov. 3 ballot, as the Pagosa Springs SUN reported. The measure would raise the county's 2% lodging tax, unchanged since voters approved it in 1987, to 6% on stays shorter than 30 days. Per the ballot language, it would start Jan. 1, 2027 and raise about $1.08 million a year: 80% for county roads, 10% for public safety and emergency dispatch, and 10% for workforce childcare. The county's rate wouldn't apply inside Town boundaries, which have their own lodging tax.
It appears as County Issue 1A on the official sample ballot. As of this writing it's a proposal, not law. Either way, rental projections for county properties written this fall should be tested at both rates.
Market conditions give buyers time to sort all this out before they commit. The Pagosa Springs Area Association of REALTORS® September 2026 report, which combines single-family homes, townhomes and condos in Archuleta County, shows 301 active listings, 128 days on market and 10.1 months of supply for September 2026. The median sold price was $695,000 that month, up 23.9% from a year earlier. That figure comes from just 35 sales.
With roughly ten months of supply, sellers usually aren't in a position to refuse a buyer's request to confirm the jurisdiction, the permit status and the renewal date before writing contingencies around them. Before relying on rental income, these are the questions to answer:
Does putting the property in an LLC avoid a new permit? In unincorporated Archuleta County, the code says a transfer between individuals and a trust or company is not a change of ownership if the same individuals stay behind it. A buyer's new LLC is a different owner from the seller. In town, the Clerk's 2025 comments described adding people to a trust as a change of ownership.
What happens to guest reservations the seller already accepted? In the county, a new owner who submits a permit application and fees within 30 days of closing can keep the prior owner's bookings, but can't advertise until approval. The 2025 reporting on Town rules describes no equivalent window.
Does the higher PLPOA assessment end if the rental stops? PLPOA ties the short-term rental assessment to county approval of a permit. How the association handles a property that stops renting is a question for PLPOA directly.
If you're weighing a Pagosa Springs home where rental income is part of the plan, it helps to confirm which rulebook applies before the offer is written. Amber Johnson can help you check jurisdiction, permit status and HOA obligations so the numbers you make your decision on are the ones that will actually hold up after closing. Let's Connect.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.